Friday, March 14, 2025
Google search engine
HomeAudioContract Law AudioAn insight into Foss v Harbottle (1843) case

An insight into Foss v Harbottle (1843) case

 

Case Law: Foss vs. Harbottle (1843)

The claimants, Foss and Turton, were shareholders in a company ‘The Victoria Park Company’ which was formed to buy land for use as a pleasure park.  The defendants were the other directors and shareholders of the company.  The claimants alleged that the defendants had defrauded the company in various ways and in particular that the defendants had sold land belonging to them to the company at exorbitant price.  The claimants now asked the court to order that the defendants make good the losses to the company.

It was held by Vice-Chancellor Wigram that since the company’s board of directors was still in existence, and since it was still possible to call a general meeting of the company, there was nothing to prevent the company from obtaining redress in its corporate character, and the action by the claimants could not be sustained.

In Foss vs. Harbottle two minority shareholders in a company alleged that its directors were guilty of buying their own land for the company’s use and paying themselves a price greater than its value.  This act of directors resulted in a loss of the company.

The minority shareholders decided to take action against the directors, but the majority shareholders in a meting resolved not to take any action against the directors alleging that they were not responsible for the loss which had occurred.

The court dismissed the suit on the ground that the acts of the directors were capable of confirmation by the majority members and held that the proper plaintiff for wrongs done to the company is the company itself and not the minority shareholders and the company can act only through majority shareholders.

Basis of the Rule

(1) The right of the Majority Rule

The court has said in some of the cases that an action by a single shareholder cannot be entertained because the feeling of the majority of the members has not been tested and that  they may be prepared to waive their right to sue.

(2) The Company is a Legal Person

The court has also said from time to time that since a company is a person at law, the action is vested in it and cannot be brought by a single member.

(3) The prevention of multiplicity of Actions

This situation could occur if each individual member was allowed to commence an action in respect of a wrong done to the company.

(4) The court’s order may be made ineffective

The court’s order could be overruled by an ordinary resolution of members in a subsequent general meeting.

 

For details and Exceptions to Foss v Horbottle, play below Audio

 

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -
Google search engine

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Aashish Mishra on Job Vacancy
dre on Quiz9 Q2
dre on Quiz9 Q3
Travis on Quiz9 Q1
Travis on Quiz9 Q2
Travis on Quiz9 Q2
Travis on Quiz9 Q3
sanco on GK1 Q1
sanco on GK1 Q4
sanco on GK1 Q6
sanco on GK1 Q8
junior on Quiz8 Q2
junior on Quiz8 Q4
junior on Quiz8 Q5
junior on Quiz8 Q7
junior on Quiz8 Q1
junior on Quiz8 Q3
junior on Quiz8 Q6
junior on Quiz8 Q8
Victor on World5 Q1
Victor on World5 Q7
demo on Book3 Q5
demo on Book3 Q3
demo on Book3 Q6
demo on Book3 Q5
demo on Book3 Q4
demo on Book3 Q2
demo on Book3 Q1
Basil2 on Quiz7 Q6
Basil2 on Quiz7 Q4
Basil2 on Quiz7 Q5
Basil2 on Quiz7 Q5
Basil2 on Quiz7 Q7
Sid on World5 Q1
Sid on World5 Q2
Sid on World5 Q3
Sid on World5 Q4
Sid on World5 Q5
Sid on World5 Q6
Sid on World5 Q7
Sid on World5 Q8
mb14 on GK1 Q7
mb14 on GK1 Q6
mb14 on GK1 Q4
mb14 on GK1 Q5
mb14 on GK1 Q3
mb14 on GK1 Q2
mb14 on GK1 Q1
mb14 on GK1 Q8
sanco on Quiz9 Q3
Michael Martens on Quiz8 Q1
Michael Martens on Quiz8 Q2
Michael Martens on Quiz8 Q4
Michael Martens on Quiz8 Q3
Michael Martens on Quiz8 Q5
Michael Martens on Quiz8 Q8
Nick Votto on World5 Q1
Nick Votto on World5 Q2
Nick Votto on World5 Q3
Nick Votto on World5 Q4
Nick Votto on World5 Q5
Nick Votto on World5 Q6
Nick Votto on World5 Q7
Nick Votto on World5 Q8
hgn on GK1 Q5
hgn on GK1 Q6
hgn on GK1 Q8
Thomas on GK1 Q1
Thomas on GK1 Q2
Thomas on GK1 Q3
Thomas on GK1 Q4
Thomas on GK1 Q5
Thomas on GK1 Q6
Thomas on GK1 Q7
Thomas on GK1 Q8
Brian Allen on GK1 Q3
Brian Allen on GK1 Q2
Brian Allen on GK1 Q2
Brian Allen on GK1 Q1
Brian Allen on Quiz9 Q1
Brian Allen on Quiz9 Q2
Brian Allen on Quiz9 Q3
Helen Carter on Quiz7 Q6
Helen Carter on Quiz7 Q4
Helen Carter on Quiz7 Q5
Helen Carter on Quiz7 Q7
Nancy Evans on Quiz8 Q1
Nancy Evans on Quiz8 Q2
Nancy Evans on Quiz8 Q3
Nancy Evans on Quiz8 Q4
Nancy Evans on Quiz8 Q5
Nancy Evans on Quiz8 Q6
Nancy Evans on Quiz8 Q7
Nancy Evans on Quiz8 Q8
James Smith on World4 Q2
James Smith on World4 Q3
James Smith on World4 Q4
James Smith on World4 Q5
James Smith on World4 Q6
James Smith on World4 Q1
Jeff King on Book3 Q5
Jeff King on Book3 Q4
Jeff King on Book3 Q3
Jeff King on Book3 Q2
Jeff King on Book3 Q1
Linda Walker on Quiz9 Q1
Linda Walker on Quiz9 Q2
Linda Walker on Quiz9 Q3
Linda Walker on World5 Q1
Linda Walker on World5 Q3
Linda Walker on World5 Q2
Linda Walker on World5 Q4
Linda Walker on World5 Q8
Linda Walker on World5 Q7
Linda Walker on World5 Q5
Linda Walker on World5 Q6
Donald Gracia on Quiz7 Q4
Donald Gracia on Quiz7 Q6
Donald Gracia on Quiz7 Q5
Donald Gracia on Quiz7 Q7
Donald Gracia on Quiz7 Q5
Donald Gracia on Quiz7 Q7
Betty Adams on GK1 Q1
Betty Adams on GK1 Q3
Betty Adams on GK1 Q3
Betty Adams on GK1 Q4
Betty Adams on GK1 Q5
Betty Adams on GK1 Q6
Betty Adams on GK1 Q7
Betty Adams on GK1 Q8
Prathibha Prakash on commerceduniya
surya prakash kumawat on Vacancies of CA Articleship in Delhi NCR
i want all ipcc exam paper of last five years on Question paper of Advanced Accounting May 2013 exam of CA IPCC
syed on commerceduniya
sonali navale on commerceduniya
ramesh on commerceduniya
jailaxmi.ece@gmail.com on Contract Law_Answer_Dec 2011
miankshee on commerceduniya
yatish lalwani on dariakoreczak@gmail.com
Parvez Virani on dariakoreczak@gmail.com
Rahul Vats on mabum2@facebook.com
Narendra Boyina on Gimme one more chestnut!
Gayatri Sinha on
cduniya on industrial_training